Nightmare
Tenth Edition · 164★
Market guide US$3.14 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
The card catalog
Browse cards
Results for “Nightmare” rare
Nightmare Unmaking
New Capenna Commander · 253
Market guide US$0.32 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Lash
Mirrodin · 219
Market guide US$12.41 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Mushu — Your Worst Nightmare
Reign of Jafar · 218
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse
Theros Beyond Death Promos · 208s
Market guide US$6.96 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse
Theros Beyond Death Promos · 208p
Market guide US$7.50 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse
Theros Beyond Death · 208
Market guide US$3.83 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Ashiok, Nightmare Weaver
Theros · 188
Market guide US$10.25 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Waking Nightmare
Champions of Kamigawa · 149
Market guide US$0.35 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Shepherd
Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander · 149
Market guide US$0.34 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Sivriss, Nightmare Speaker
Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate · 148
Market guide US$0.25 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Mushu — Your Worst Nightmare
Reign of Jafar · 142
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander · 133
Market guide US$4.20 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Unmaking
Wilds of Eldraine Commander · 114
Market guide US$0.33 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Sower
Lorwyn Eclipsed · 114
Market guide US$0.31 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Shepherd
Theros Beyond Death Promos · 108s
Market guide US$2.08 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Shepherd
Theros Beyond Death Promos · 108p
Market guide US$0.50 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Shepherd
Theros Beyond Death · 108
Market guide US$0.42 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Waking Nightmare
Modern Masters 2015 · 103
Market guide US$0.25 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Void
Ravnica: City of Guilds · 100
Market guide US$0.37 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Collective Nightmare
March of the Machine · 95
Market guide US$0.05 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Hopeless Nightmare
Wilds of Eldraine · 95
Market guide US$0.54 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Hunted Nightmare
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 92s
Market guide US$0.30 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Hunted Nightmare
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths Promos · 92p
Market guide US$0.34 From €0.30 × 1.117206 · ECB, 2026-10-30 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Hunted Nightmare
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths · 92
Market guide US$0.31 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Elspeth's Nightmare
Theros Beyond Death · 91
Market guide US$0.37 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Startled Awake // Persistent Nightmare
Shadows over Innistrad Promos · 88s
Market guide US$2.59 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Startled Awake // Persistent Nightmare
Shadows over Innistrad · 88
Market guide US$2.83 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Dominaria United Promos · 84s
Market guide US$7.51 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Dominaria United Promos · 84p
Market guide US$6.60 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Dominaria United · 84
Market guide US$5.39 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Chthonian Nightmare
Modern Horizons 3 Promos · 83s
Market guide US$3.23 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Chthonian Nightmare
Modern Horizons 3 · 83
Market guide US$0.98 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Edge of Eternities Commander · 82
Market guide US$3.86 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Nightmare Void
Duel Decks: Izzet vs. Golgari · 73
Market guide US$0.09 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Recurring Nightmare
Exodus · 72
Market guide US$80.81 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare // Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Dominaria United Art Series · 66
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
The Ultimate Nightmare of Wizards of the Coast® Customer Service
Unglued · 53
Market guide US$0.93 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Sivriss, Nightmare Speaker // Sivriss, Nightmare Speaker
Battle for Baldur's Gate Art Series · 51
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Nightmare Incursion
Eventide · 40
Market guide US$8.03 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Chainer, Nightmare Adept
Commander 2019 · 39
Market guide US$0.90 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Chthonian Nightmare // Chthonian Nightmare
Modern Horizons 3 Art Series · 37
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Sivriss, Nightmare Speaker // Sivriss, Nightmare Speaker
Battle for Baldur's Gate Art Series · 32
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare // Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Dominaria United Art Series · 23
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
King Candy — Sugar Rush Nightmare
Reign of Jafar · 23
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Collective Nightmare // Collective Nightmare
March of the Machine Art Series · 22
Price unavailable No connected source has a price for this printing and condition yet.
0
Nightmare Unmaking
Commander 2019 · 20
Market guide US$0.26 Nonfoil · Nonfoil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0
Braids, Arisen Nightmare
Game Day Promos · 8
Market guide US$28.59 Foil · Foil · Reference price, not a condition-specific valuation Scryfall · 2026-11-01
0